Speeches full of cliches, a lack of strategy on Brexit and a failure to recognise the value and importance of the travel industry. This was the damning verdict on the UK’s main political parties by a panel of senior figures from across the travel industry, speaking at a special TTG Debate on Monday.
Julia Lo Bue-Said, managing director of The Advantage Travel Partnership; Alan Wardle, Abta’s director of public affairs; Steven Freudmann, chairman of the Institute of Travel and Tourism; and Gareth Morgan, director at public affairs consultancy Cavendish and advisor to the Guild of Travel and Management Companies (GTMC) all discussed how Thursday’s result could impact the sector.
First up was how the panellists planned to vote in this election. Moderator TTG editor Sophie Griffiths quizzed them as to whether they would be voting with their head or their heart. For Lo Bue-Said, the answer was simple: “My head – this time around there are so many important issues for the industry.”
Wardle admitted that his “head and heart have been arguing over this one”, while Freudmann said: “For me, it’s both.” Morgan seemed to sum up the mood of the room however, as he confessed: “I slightly resent having to vote at all; the state of the two main leaders is the worst I’ve seen.”
Examining which party manifesto offers the best opportunity for travel, the panellists agreed there was an overall failure to address any key issues. “I have to say the manifestos were missing anything specific regarding the travel industry,” said Freudmann. “When May called this election, I assumed we would start hearing about Brexit. All we’ve heard are cliches. I’m disappointed no party has defined what would be a good or a bad Brexit deal.”
Wardle added: “This is the first election in 50 years when the focus has not been on the economy. May is saying no deal is better than a bad deal, but we have to have a deal for aviation.”
Brexit was, of course, the main topic. Lo Bue-Said acknowledged the difficulties facing Theresa May, who has been accused of failing to provide any detail of how she will approach the discussions. “If I’m going into negotiations at work, I would not be showing my hand,” Lo Bue-Said said. “I don’t want my PM to say what she wants before she goes into it.”
Freudmann was more scathing. “The cynical view is that they [the Conservatives] don’t have a strategy. I don’t believe there is a cabinet view on what is a good deal. Open skies are an absolute must, as is visa-free travel. Nobody is discussing this.”
Meanwhile, political lobbyist Morgan hinted at significant cracks in the Conservative party’s support of May and her approach to Brexit. “I would not underestimate the splits at the top of government,” he revealed. “There are certain Cabinet sub-committees where May is isolated. Some Brexit policy is completely decided by a small clique around May.”
